Gotta Invest in ’Em All
How on earth are Pokémon cards worth more than some houses; after all, they're just cards—right?
I never got to grow up with the golden age of Pokémon. I was born 20 days before Pokémon Platinum arrived in North America, and years after the last Generation 3 events finished. Forced to live through this era by watching the anime on repeat 5 years after their release, the theme song “Gotta Catch ‘Em All” has since been ingrained in my mind.
Although the first game—Pocket Monsters Red and Green (later changed to Pokémon in 1998)—preceded the collectible cards by a few years, today, if you bring up Pokémon to anyone, they are bound to think of the cards.
For years, people bought booster boxes to “pull” cool cards, keep as a sealed collectable, or even play the niche trading card game. This was back when people actually played, touched, and admired their cards. I myself had a few “rare” cards, beat up as they were brought to and from school to trade with friends. That all changed in October of 2020.
Logan Paul's charity stream, where he opened a 1st edition booster box from 1999, was the cataclysmic event that tore the Pokémon collecting community wide open. Suddenly, people who had never been exposed to Pokémon cards realised a fundamental truth: there was real money to this game. Given this was the same audience that bought Paul’s failed NFT CryptoZoo as an “investment opportunity”, there was no doubt that they too would hop on this trend.
Together with the pandemic, more and more people began engaging with Pokémon in the pursuit of profit instead of passion. With that, Pokémon prices skyrocketed: sealed, boosters, blisters, raw, graded, and all other Pokémon products averaged a 600% annual return in the spring of 2021. People were bound to buy into this bull market—after all, these are the same returns stock brokers have wet dreams about. More and more people began engaging with Pokémon in the pursuit of profit instead of passion.
Brought about by the increased demand from both new collector hobbyists and financially motivated people looking to diversify their portfolio, the supposed “Pokémon economic bubble” kept on growing, with no signs of slowing down. With that, two different markets emerged: vintage and modern.
Vintage, I get; after all, pristine 20-year-old cards are bound to be expensive, especially considering how mainstream Pokémon has gotten in recent years—high demand, low supply, yada yada yada. So fine, I’ll hold my breath when people buy a PSA10 Skyridge Holo Gengar for $300,000 (which sold for only $10,000 seven months earlier). For their sake, I really hope they actually care about the card.
Like many other long-term fans of Pokémon, I am sick and tired of the modern market—or the fact that a modern market even exists—on the other hand, I hate. You’d assume the demand would be driven by actual fans; the real culprits, however, are resellers. Resellers, unaffectionately named scalpers by the larger community, are a plague contaminating card collecting.
Scalpers buy up sealed Elite Trainer Boxes, Booster Bundles, and Singles to sell for an astronomically high price tag. The only way to rid these products of their hosts’ greedy hands? Pay triple their original value and be grateful you even got your hands on Pokémon.
I suppose I can’t blame them though for trying to make money; after all, when all you need to do is ask Claude to create a bot that buys up new drops or wait outside a Costco overnight to make a quick 300% return, it doesn’t get much easier than that.
Recently, and thankfully, Pokémon found a way to combat the scalping contagion, through a vaccine only they could manufacture: supply. The anticipation for Pokémon’s new 30th Anniversary Set was high, and while people across the internet were worrying in Reddit forums and Instagram reel comments, Pokémon was producing the new cards en-mass. Scalpers, previously profiting on the high demand, were now burdened by a massive influx in supply. For the first time in recent years, Pokémon became completely unscalpable.
Selfishly, I’m still mad at Logan Paul, though I'm glad Pokémon is finally getting its flowers. I wish the hype-driven demand driven by the socio-economic state of the world that allowed my (add adjective) hobby to become an actually viable financial investment didn’t exist. One day, I hope Pokemon cards fully escape from the grasp of greedy scalpers and feel the warmth of a kid’s dorito-dusted hand or the protection of a penny sleeve, and go back to the lighthearted fun of Gotta Catch ‘Em All.